In its decision of 16 September 2026 (UPC-CoA-919/2025 and UPC-CoA-920/2025), the Court of Appeal addressed this question in a very practical context (§§315-319).
To establish prior use, the alleged infringer (defendant) relied on measurements performed in 2024 on remaining stocks of silver powder batches allegedly used in products manufactured ten years earlier. The Patentee disputed, without being able to substantiate its denial, that the samples measured in 2024 actually came from these old batches.
Under Rule 171.2 RoP, such an unspecific denial could in principle have resulted in the defendant’s allegation being deemed undisputed. Yet, the Court of Appeal held that a party cannot be required to substantiate a denial where the relevant fact lies outside its sphere of knowledge and responsibility.
Here, whether the samples came from the defendant’s remaining stocks was an internal matter exclusively within its organisation. The patentee could therefore legitimately declare that it had no knowledge of that fact. The defendant’s allegation was not deemed undisputed and had to be proved. The defendant ultimately did so through written witness statements.
Key takeaway: Rule 171.2 RoP requires parties to specifically contest factual allegations. However, where a fact lies exclusively within the opposing party’s sphere of knowledge and responsibility, a declaration of lack of knowledge may be sufficient. The fact is then not deemed undisputed; rather, it requires proof. Thus, when opponents rely on facts that only they can know, do not hesitate to challenge them and ask for proof !
octobre 2026