Following the preliminary injunction granted by the UPC Court of Appeal in April 2026, the legal battle between Merz an Viatris based on an SPC covering fampridine continues with two successive orders from UPC Paris Local Division, that address key procedural issues arising from the dispute, including lis pendens, related actions and bifurcation.
1. First order: No lis pendens, but related actions
On April 16, 2026, Viatris brought an action before French Court of First Instance seeking, inter alia, revocation of Merz’s SPC and a declaration of non-infringement. In parallel, Merz filed an infringement action on the merits before the UPC Paris Local Division on May 28, 2026, within the time limit set out in the preliminary injunction order.
In the order UPC-CFI-0001901/2026 of July 30, 2026, the judge rapporteur held that :
• The French Court was seised first, as provisional measures and actions on the merits constitute separate proceedings;
• No lis pendens existed according to Article 29 Brussels I bis, due to the different subject matter and causes of action;
• The actions were nevertheless related under Article 30 Brussels I bis, since they involved the same parties, SPC and facts;
• A stay was refused, as the UPC was likely to rule before the French court and a stay would delay the proceedings.
2. Second order: Bifurcation of infringement and revocation proceedings.
On September 11, 2026, Viatris filed a counterclaim for revocation of the SPC before the UPC, arguing that this action has created a new lis pendens situation with the earlier French revocation proceedings, and requested bifurcation and stay of the revocation proceedings pending a final decision by the French court on its jurisdiction.
In the order UPC-CFI-0001901/2026 & UPC_CFI_3259/2026 of October, 15, 2026, the full panel:
• Ordered bifurcation under Article 33.3.b) UPCA, and referred the counterclaim for revocation to the Paris Central Division, noting that both parties agreed to such a referral;
• Retained the infringement action before the Paris Local Division;
• Left the stay request to the assessment of Paris Central Division, without determining whether the conditions for lis pendens were met.
Key takeaway:
These orders highlight several important procedural considerations when UPC and national litigation are running in parallel:
First, an application for provisional measures does not establish priority of referral for subsequent proceedings on the merits.
Second, prior national revocation proceedings do not necessarily prevent subsequent infringement proceedings before the UPC from moving forward. Bifurcation may allow validity-related issues, including potential lis pendens, to be addressed separately while avoiding delays to the infringement proceedings.
octobre 2026