SANTARELLI

What are you looking for?

Enter at least 2 characters.

Esc to close

In an Order dated August 27, 2026 (UPC_CoA_76/2026), in the case Xingi Technology CO., Ltd, Jiangsu Jiuzhou High-Performance Fiber ProductsCO., Ltd VS. Avient Protective Materials B.V., the UPC Court of Appeal confirmed the conditions under which a party may obtain the production of evidence held by its opponent pursuant to Rule 190 of the Rules of Procedure (RoP).

The dispute concerned a patent relating to multifilament yarns and ballistic products incorporating such yarns. Avient (i.e. the patentee) alleged that the Xingi companies (i.e. the defendants) were marketing several products that infringed, among others, claims requiring specific parameter thresholds for ballistic panels, measured against specified projectiles. After the defendants argued that infringement could not be established without actual ballistic testing, Avient sought the production of samples pursuant to R. 190 RoP to enable such testing. The first instance’s judge-rapporteur granted their request in that it ordered provision of two product families (among those asked for).

The Court of Appeal upheld that order and recalls that R. 190 RoP is intended to address information asymmetries that may arise where relevant evidence lies exclusively within the control of the opposing party or a third party. First, such measures may be granted only on the basis of specific and substantiated allegations and cannot serve exploratory or speculative purposes. Then, the requested evidence must be strictly necessary and the requested measure must be proportionate. Finally, the Court must ensure a fair balance between competing rights, including the protection of confidential information, trade secrets and personal data. Rule 190 RoP therefore permits targeted and justified access to specific evidence, but neither general disclosure nor discovery.

The Court provides two important clarifications. First, the fact that a party considers the evidence already produced sufficient to establish infringement does not prevent it from seeking additional evidence where it demonstrates a legitimate interest in obtaining it—particularly where its opponent itself argues that the disputed fact can be established only by means of such evidence. Second, neither Article 59 UPCA nor Rule 190 RoP requires a request for production of evidence to be filed with the Statement of claim. Whether the request is timely filed must be assessed in light of the state of the proceedings.

Key takeaway: Order for evidence production measures pursuant to R. 190 RoP may be obtained, provided they are necessary, proportionate and reasonably supported. The request can be filed after the Statement of claim, where justified by the state of the proceedings and subsequent procedural developments, such as arguments raised in the Statement of defence.

Paul-Marie Toutain, ingénieur brevet chez Santarelli

Paul-Marie Toutain
Patent Attorney

Patent

The Guitar Structure, Materials, and Innovations

Trademark

“Divine” VS “Gaultier Divine”

UPC

One SPC, two Courts: Navigating lis pendens and bifurcation before the UPC