SANTARELLI

What are you looking for?

Enter at least 2 characters.

Esc to close

In its recent decision of 16 September 2026 (UPC-CoA-919/2025 and UPC-CoA-920/2025), the UPC Court of Appeal confirmed that a final national judgment may prevent the UPC from reconsidering the validity of the same national part of a European patent.

However, res judicata is not necessarily an absolute bar to a subsequent validity challenge before the UPC under Rule 362 RoP. Its effect depends on:
• what was actually covered by the final national judgment, including the grounds on which validity was challenged; and
• the national law governing the res judicata effect of that judgment.

In the present case, the German Federal Patent Court had previously upheld the German part of EP 3 215 288 in amended form, following a validity challenge based on novelty and inventive step. That judgment had become final. The Court of Appeal confirms that those issues were covered by res judicata. However, the German part of the patent could still be challenged on other grounds not covered by the previous judgment, such as insufficiency, insofar as German law permits such a subsequent challenge.

This means that the conditions and scope of res judicata are to be determined by what was decided in the earlier judgement and by the law of the Member State in which that judgement was given.

Key takeaway: Before challenging a patent before the UPC, check not only whether it has already been litigated nationally, but also exactly which grounds were decided and what res judicata effect the relevant national law gives to that decision !

Gabrielle Faure-André, Ingénieure Brevets chez Santarelli, cabinet de propriété intellectuelle.

Gabrielle Faure-André
Patent Attorney

Patent

Development and Protection of New Technologies for the Olympic Games

Les Directives chinoises du 8 novembre 2024 relatives à la concurrence en matière de brevets essentiels aux normes : un cadre juridique renforcé pour un secteur stratégique

Trademark

China: Additional Publications to Optimize the Protection of Your Trademarks

Globe terrestre entouré de représentations de différents territoires et de dessins techniques de produits, illustrant la protection internationale des dessins et modèles.

Designs

International Designs: A path strewn with pitfalls